If you’ve never experienced a Phil Elverum project before (Mount Eerie, the Microphones, other K Records stuff of the early ’00s), I cannot recommend listening to Wind’s Poem.
As a previous Microphones fanatic, though, I can only speak of the album through my expectations.
Mr. Elverum has not strayed from his major-key, 5 note melodies, nor has his lyrical powers moved beyond the awkwardness of his earlier, more emo-tinged work. “My heart a frozen boulder” always stuck out in every listen. His words are more removed form his emotions this time, making the content he covers more distanced, more cerebral. It seems like he’s attempting to construct a metaphysical landscape out of his relationship with nature. But as my wife exclaimed on one car ride: “Those words just don’t fit!! [laughing]” It’s true, the rhythm of the words are sometimes incredibly clunky. I am sometimes inspired by philosophical texts, but their jargon is not the stuff of songs.
Wind’s Poem is made up, on the larger scale, of two different style of sound: loud, abrasive and simple; and gentle, meandering, and simple.
1. Loud songs. Walls of loud guitars and a wash of cymbals. Mr. Elverum’s voice comes in occasionally, but the mix has no room for him. This competition of sound makes for an unsatisfying listen. I tended to skip these song for that reason. The songs perpetuate themselves with a droning note or chord, perhaps to build tension before moving to the next note or chord. This gives that incredible sense of walking through waist-high sludge when executed successfully, but the muddy mix (no pun intended) causes it to simply feel like an extended wait until the next note or chord! Oh no!
2. Soft songs. These have always been Mr. Elverum’s strong point and Wind’s Poem is no exception. Each song has an interesting sonic space and arrangement. His vocals don’t compete as much in the mix, though being able to distinguish the words are not always desirable, as I stated.
I struggled, though, as I said in my previous post, with the energy of the record. These soft songs feel motionless. They feel largely uninspired. Like they were written in a period of numbness. Whereas Mr. Elverum’s work as the Microphones was powered by his strong emotional feelings, these songs feel like they lack that compositional will to be. He has some nice melodies, some interesting arrangements – the record is fairly well-crafted. It’s lacking energy, though. But that’s purely my intuition. Nothing objective.
If you are interested, here are the tracks that I particularly enjoyed. “Between Two Mysteries” is particularly great! That track comes highly recommended.
8. Between Two Mysteries ****
9. Ancient Questions
11. Lost Wisdom pt. 2
12. Stone’s Ode
Note on the reviews of the record: too much attention paid to Wind’s Poem’s debt to metal. Other than loud, abrasive guitars, moving in unison, I just didn’t think it was such an important factor in experiencing the album. No double-bass drum, no screeching/guttural vocals. Then again, my understanding of metal is limited. To me, this record sounded just like his other records. No additional references necessary.
